Harry Potter…Evil or Entertainment?

Fiction, Uncategorized

Recently I re-read most of the Harry Potter books for the release of the newest movie. I wondered as I was reading what people in the religious world thought of the books. I remember the uproar in the churches when these books were first released. I remember hearing from the pulpit how evil these books were and to stay away from them. At the time I hadn’t read them and I thought that every preacher that was preaching against them had…so…I wanted to read them and see what was so bad about this particular series.

Well, I read them and I have to say that I don’t think many preachers have read the whole series. I do believe that if you’re going to preach against a book, you need to have read it so you can defend your views to those who have read it. As for evil, there are all sorts of evils in the book, but they are usually cast in that exact light. Harry, the main character, is a pre-teen who strives to be a good friend, and have loyalty to those whom he cares for. If anything, this is a great example, for pre-teens especially because today the mentality is “me first”. Harry puts his friends and “family” (staff of Hogwarts) first. I think this sends a great message.

I know that the church’s main concern with the Harry Potter series is the magic that is a central part of the books. The bible does speak against sorcerers, but the majority who read these books aren’t looking to become “dark lords”.  As a parent, or a reader, you have to be careful that you’re mature enough to resist any pull into the world of the “dark arts”. These books are written as fiction and for entertainment. I really enjoyed them, but I wasn’t tempted to become a sorceress.

I really enjoy these books because they give you a glimpse into another world. A world that we can only enter into through these books. I do not consider these books evil, but I do want to warn you to read them as fiction. Enjoy them and let me know what you think!

4 Comments

4 Comments

  1. Linda  •  Aug 17, 2009 @9:31 pm

    I disagree that these are for ‘entertainment’ any more than The Third Reich, and that one attached itself to me spiritually and I didn’t figure it out for 25 years, and I read it in high school! Torturous visions appeared all the time in my mind and I couldn’t figure out why. After seeing parts of a documentary on WWII with my husband did I figure it out. All books have a ’spiritual’ dimension to them and affect people differently. Most of the kids who read Harry Potter had/have no clue of that world. But that doesn’t matter, the door for evil is opened when one reads stuff like this. Same with the Oiuji board.

  2. admin  •  Aug 17, 2009 @9:57 pm

    We do have to be careful in the way we read any material. Christians should always be on guard for their soul. A major difference between the Harry Potter series and the Ouija board is that the books aren’t something to participate in, but something to be read as fiction. If you have a child that can’t understand that Harry Potter is fiction, then I wouldn’t recommend that you allow them to read it.

    The Third Reich was all too real, a true horror that still haunts many today. That’s something very different from a work of fiction that doesn’t entice people to do evil.

    As always, if you believe it is wrong, then you shouldn’t read it!

  3. Jessica  •  Aug 18, 2009 @11:15 am

    Comparing the reaction that one gets from reading a book about the VERY REAL slaughter of 11 million innocent people and a book about wizards fighting evil is incredibly demeaning to those people who died and whose family died in the Holocaust. There is no comparison between the fictional sequences in a novel, and watching a documentary showing the deaths of real people.

  4. Elizabeth  •  Dec 13, 2009 @3:36 pm

    I don’t think it’s demeaning at all. She was simply stating how another book she had read stuck in her spirit. Christians need to be aware of how consuming things that promote evil (I can’t find anywhere in scripture that sorcery is referred to anything BUT that) can effect them spiritually. We shouldn’t foolishly say that something isn’t wrong because it doesn’t “bother.” Maybe the question we should ask is why something the Word defines as evil *doesn’t* bother us.

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>